Originally Posted by jonn3

Never forget the first time my buddy shot in my mouth - we had always warned each other before we came so we could stop sucking -

Well I was going down on his dick and suddenly he says "I'm gonna..." and he shot deep in my throat.

Now I had been curious what would it would taste like but had never wanted to suggest such a thing - that might sound gay

Well after he kept apologizing - but then using teenage logic he had a way to make it up to me. Since he came in my mouth I should get to cum in his.

And after that we never warned each other again before we shot.